Score: 9

"Great 3D Game"

submission: 'Geom 3D

date: March 19, 2008

That was awesome. 3D Flash games usually impress me and this was no exception, I'd like to try some real 3D in Flash myself one day (I've had a play with pseudo 3D) but wouldn't really know where to start.

I found the first level of this game to be a weak start, the movement of the enemies was far too erratic which made it difficult to avoid them. You had some great ideas here but it didn't really come together.

The game got better when it went to the more track racing style, I still found it pretty tricky to judge jumps but it was generally good fun. The tracks were well designed and must've taken a while to do.

Graphically it was simple, but given that it was 3D I'd still say it looked fantastic. I liked the use of bright colours and strong geometric shapes.

Music was good, a fitting choice. Lack of SFX though, these would've helped the game a lot I reckon.

Really liked your menus and things, this was a well presented game. Especially liked that whoosh effect when you die, felt like something straight from a console game (well maybe DS, not exactly a PS3 level of advancement).

This was pretty much my favorite thing I've found on Newgrounds today, I don't often leave reviews so that must go to show how cool I thought this was. Keep up the good work and I'll look out for your stuff!

Score: 10

"An excellent shooter"

submission: Cyborg.

date: December 29, 2007

This is probably the best game I've played on Newgrounds this month. I particularly enjoyed it as it has similarities to one of my own games, but the gameplay and effects were truly outstanding.

I'll start by saying I played up to the level with the lightsaber-type weapon, so my judgment is based only on the levels up until then (when I have a while to spare I'll no doubt come back and play some more).

Other than the ad, the game looks impressive before the user even reaches the game. Loved the menu, nothing too flashy but the effect on the background was unique and set the game's feel right away. Changeable clothes and hair was a nice touch, from my experience such a feature can limit the capabilities of animating the character, but I didn't notice any such problems.

The character's movement was fluid, the rocket pack feature was a nice touch that gave the game some originality. To where I played I didn't find it absolutely necessary though and I'll be interested to see if the later levels make better use of the feature. Same goes for the boost-running.

A roll feature would have added to the gameplay, when left or right is pressed whilst crouching. I think there'd be something satisfying about rolling towards an enemy to dodge its fire before slashing it in half with the lightsaber thing.

The sound effects were brilliant, there always seemed to be an assortment of sounds going on at once which made the gameplay feel enjoyably hectic. The music I can't credit so much, fitting perhaps, but there may have been better choices.

My very favorite thing about the game was the laser effects. This surely must have been AS3 coded, because I'd be amazed if you could get so many laser blasts going at once without lag in AS2. Loved the way laser rebounded slightly on contact with a wall.

By the third level I could see the game getting repetitive, but you skillfully managed to keep it constantly varied. It's very hard to stop playing a game when you're always being given a new weapon to play with or a new type of challenge.

There's a lot I liked about this game that I haven't even mentioned - the cutscene at the start, the slick status display, the great enemy design, high quality artwork throughout. There's more than enough here to make the game deserved of a 10/10, it's as good as Flash shooting games get.

Score: 8

"Very good idea, just a bit buggy"

submission: Santa Sniper

date: December 21, 2007

I'll start by saying that the is very well presented, great menus etc. The graphics are very good on Santa, the background is decent but a little bare in places.

The concept of Santa sniping Scrooges is very original, and for the most part it was well conceived. I like the way it zooms in, really cool effect, and the shakiness is nice too.

There's just some serious cases of it not doing what you'd expect. For ages I couldn't work out why I couldn't hold my breath - it was because I was holding CTRL. But when I started just pressing it to enter zoom mode, the crosshair didn't seem to line up right.

A 'back to menu' button would also be a good idea because, probably like most people, I dived right into the game and missed the instructions, so I had to start over.

The sound is ok, but didn't fit very well. Something Christmassy would've made it a lot better. SFX were fine though.

Overall it was a well made game, but feels like it needs a lot of refinement. Can't help but think you rushed it a little to get it out in time for Christmas. Based on the coding, concept and art (and a little bit of personal bias) I'll give this an 8, nice try.

Score: 10

"Fast, stylish and fun"

submission: Vector Runner

date: November 29, 2007

3D games in Flash, they don't come along often so I'm always excited to find a new one, especially one as good as this. My attention span doesn't keep me hooked on games long, but I could've played this forsome time if I didn't have better things to do (will add to my favourites and no doubt come back to it later though!).

I'd be very interested to know if this is AS2 or AS3. The sheer speed of it is amazing, when I played it I figured it was AS3 but after seeing your comment about Flash struggling with it I'm not so sure. Either way, the coding is very good to get it playing this well.

I'm in two minds about the graphics. It has a nice style to it, and does look pretty cool when all those red things are flying past at speed. But on the other hand the obstacles look too similar to each other and the ship is a bit boring as just a box. I like the look you've tried for, but I think it could be better.

Can't say anything bad about the sound, fitting music and FX, liked that whoosh when you get close to an obstacle. Always good to see off buttons though, especially as you had separate ones for music and sound, wish everyone would do that.

This is usually where I'd give suggestions for improvements, and although I can think of a lot of ideas for this, in a way they'd all draw away from the games simplicity which is largely what I liked about it. In this sense the game is perfect for what it is, so I'm giving it a 10. I'd love to see what you'd come up with if you did make a sequel though. Great work and hope you get front page.

Score: 9

"Best Line Avoider I've Played"

submission: - Desert Rally -

date: November 26, 2007

Line avoiding games have become one of my least favourite types of games on Newgrounds, I've seen people try and make the concept more interesting but it generally still results in frustration and repetitiveness. I'm not sure if you'd even class this as a line avoider, but the basic concept is still there, you've just done an excellent job of making it more varied and entertaining.

Graphics were great, room for improvement, but generally very crisp and colourful. Especially liked the car selection with it's nice array of characters. Shame you couldn't make these out too well whilst driving.

Music was fine, and the inclusion of an off button is always welcome. Sound effects were mostly ok, I had one unpleasant sound that seemed to get stuck in loop on occasion, not sure if that was a bug or intentional.

The gameplay was generally very fun, loved the open track with a choice of routes, and the occasional rotation was unique and helped vary the gameplay. The powerups were well conceived too, nothing too original, but the ones used enhanced the gameplay without distracting from the general concept.

I found it became quite difficult to see where I was going later on, I expect this was intentional to make things harder, but maybe this could have been achieved through other challenges like moving obstacles (presuming there were none of these after the point at which I died).

With only one track there wasn't much replay value, definitely scope here for multiple courses. How about an ice track with reduced friction in icy areas, or a space track with anti-gravity areas. I understand that designing mutiple tracks would take a lot more time so I'm not discrediting this one for not having them, but it's something to consider if you were to make a sequel.

The mouse-click button had no function in this game, which is something else you could add for a future version. The most basic option would be a jump feature to avoid gaps in the track or jump over opponents. Alternatively you could add weapons and use the click to fire them, I think it's awesome to collect missiles and launch them at opponents.

There's no single reason why I'm giving this a 9 instead of a 10, I think there's just too much scope for improvement to suggest that it's perfect. I really liked the game though and I'd love to see a sequel one day. Great work, well done.

Score: 9

"Phat Turkey"

submission: Fat Turkey

date: November 21, 2007

Pretty fun for a collect-and-avoid game, the graphics were well drawn and made it more enjoyable. Liked the blood spat when you hit a hunter, little odd how the hunters vanish though. The background was ok but maybe some surroundings would have made it seem less flat, even just something simple like a fence or trees around the edge.

The game difficulty was well adjusted, it sped up quick enough to keep a player interested. Could have used some more variation after a while, maybe a different type of enemy, such as hunters that can shoot.

Powerups would've definitely helped here, things like speed-up, temporary invincibility, one-hit shields. With a bit of thought to keep them in with the Turkey theme they could work well.

The sound was cool, had a retro feel to it that suited the gameplay. But an 'off' button is really a necessity in a game, not everyone will want to listen to the music and effects. Also, a 'return to menu' button is always a good idea.

The menus were one of the best things about this game, and showed how good presentation can greatly elevate a simple game. Very well drawn graphics on the title screen, and I loved the sliding effect between menus. Will probably steal this idea for my games!

Seasonal games always have added interest, even though we don't have Thanksgiving here in the UK I can see how it would get people in the seasonal mood. How about more of these; Fat Easter Bunny, Fat Jack O Lantern, Fat Guy Fawkes, Fat Cupid, Fat Leprechaun. But not Fat Santa cause that'd be lame ; )

This probably won't get daily awards or front page, but should definitely get put in the Thanksgiving collection. Time to go try get on the high score board, keep up the good work ^^

Score: 9

"Really good game"

submission: Roll

date: October 25, 2007

This is a great game, surprised it hasn't scored higher. Maybe people are having problems loading it? I'd be shocked if it's got the score it has on gameplay alone.

I found it very fun to play - fast moving, easy to control, great physics. Graphically it was crisp and well designed. The music was unintrusive and helped the gameplay.

I think I noticed a few bugs, I'm sure I lost a level but was told I completed it. Maybe I missed something though, it was all moving very fast.

It's an original concept, reminiscent of pool/snooker games but presented in a very different way. The gameplay could've been repetitive, but a good variety of obstacles and solutions made it pretty addictive.

Very little reason for my to knock marks off this, I'm only reluctant to give it a 10 for lack of character, maybe this would be better with some kind of theme. I wouldn't like to say it needs a story, but just something to give the player more incentive to be getting the balls down the holes. The name 'Roll' is quite uninspiring.

Overall this is very impressive, especially as it appears to be your first submission. I'll look forwards to seeing if you come out with anything else.

Score: 10

"Great adventure game"

submission: Jack French #3

date: October 16, 2007

Loved the first two chapters of this series and was excited to see the third on Newgrounds. The comparatively low score surprises me as i think this is just as good as the last one.

Graphically its mostly very good. Some of the background are excellent and characters are generally well drawn. A few graphics here and there look a bit rushed, but its generally impressive.

Voice acting is perfect again, good choices for each character. I only noticed a dip in quality when characters shouted. The background music was mild but atmospheric.

I can't say I got very far, after exploring all of the Casino I couldn't find anything else to do. Not sure why I wasn't finding any items, some things such as the wad of money under the couch seemed like they should be retrievable but I couldn't figure out a way to take them.

I also noticed a small bug, I received a notice of Sam Blacks apartment being available some time after visiting it already. I'm not sure if bugs like this could cause a stuck-game situation, but maybe some more testing would have been a good idea.

This series is one of the best Point n Clicks on Newgrounds, the plots are very well thought out and the puzzles requires some though. As with most point n click adventures sometimes its a little unobvious as to what to do next, for future installments how about a journal of some kind to help the player along?

Not quite to Broken Sword quality but a great game and one I'm sure a lot of people will enjoy! 10/10

Score: 9

"Fun fun fun"

submission: Doggy Drag

date: October 5, 2007

A pretty simple concept with some original twists that made it fun and addictive to play.

The movement was great, smooth and accurate. I especially liked the physics on the string pulling the man. Instead of bones appearing you need to sniff them out which was a nice idea.

Some nice graphics in there, the Game Over screen was well drawn. The background could have been improved, instead of just grass it could have been a more detailed background with more around the edge.

Things didn't change much between levels, more variation could be brought in as the game progresses. The game could be fleshed out with some kind of upgrade system and checkpoints.

As a quick time wasting game, this works great. Just missed out a daily award I see, maybe next time. 9/10, nice work.

Score: 7

"An interesting game"

submission: [Borealis]

date: September 25, 2007

An interesting take on the classic avoider type of game. Although it was graphically simple I liked the look of it, white on pink gave it a nice mellow atmosphere.

The reviewer below me said there was no real point, and I can kind of see where he's coming from. After surviving for as long as I could there was no real incentive to give it another go. A series of stages, or even something as simple as a ranking, would make this more replayable.

I wasn't too keen on the choice of music here, I'd have gone for something more mellow to match the graphics, without being too slow. Could have been a worse choice, but I don't think it was the best.

What I liked about the gameplay was that there was a lot to concentrate on, thinking about where to move for the most stars whilst keeping an eye on the meter and where to create the next bubble. Some may say it was a little too much, but I enjoyed it.

Although I thought it was a good, original game I can't help feeling that there's something missing, so I can't go higher than a 7/10 here. I'll be fiving it though and I'll look out for what you come up with next.