Score: 6

"Strangely enjoyable"

submission: Pix- ex- el V.3

date: September 1, 2005

The graphics are very simple, the concept is nothign new and fairly dull (click & shoot, repeat over).

But there is something about this that makes it really worthwhile. I'm not sure what, it could be the music combined with the SFX. I hope others agree with me and this survives.

Your future work could be something to look forwards to.

Score: 9

"Cute game"

submission: Diver Duck!

date: September 1, 2005

I really liked that, graphically it was excellent and played really smoothly.

The SFX were perfect, a touch of music might have helped.

It didn't have much replay value, pretty good for wasting 2 minutes but the fun doesn't stretch for much longer.

4/5

Score: 10

"Best so far"

submission: Buffy: TVS -conclusion-

date: August 31, 2005

I really liked this, it was my favourite so far. The story was more tightly woven and it was more gripping to watch.

A couple of suggestions:

-The fight scene was weak, SFX would help a lot and just a bit of blood too.
-I didn't like the ending, made it impossible to fit with the show. You should make your next one like a lost episode, sort of like Choas Bleeds.

But other than that it was excellent, I'm loving your work. Any chance you could put your email in your profile?

Score: 4

"They keep getting worse..."

submission: Foamy: Hurricane Special

date: August 30, 2005

I used to be a huge fan of this series. I watched every single movie. I gave the recent entries 5 despite being critical in my reviews. But this was beyond disappointing.

To be honest I think a lot of people have voted higher because its you. I voted as if this was a new submission, and hence gave it 1/5.

I won't go into reasons, you knew them before you even submitted. If you can't make these as good as they were, try something totally different, or you'll start losing fans.

Score: 9

"Excellent! But not so much."

submission: Buffy: A Random Story

date: August 29, 2005

Hey, me again, had to check out your other stuff.

This is still a great movie for the same reasons as before. But the new one is a big improvement.

The randomness just annoyed me. Why did Dark Willow have red hair and a pink shirt? And Spike wasn't around for the Dark Willow saga...

There's always the chamce that this was another period of evil willow, maybe she's been put under control in season 7? If so a little explanation would be nice.....

But that aside, it was still fun to watch and brought back fond Buffy memories. Can't wait for more.

Oh and I forgot in my last review... SERENITY SERENITY SERENITY, I've seen a prescreeening, its AMAZING.

Score: 10

"Excellent!"

submission: Buffy The Vampire Slayer

date: August 29, 2005

That was so great! I don't know where to start...

The graphics were really nice, I liked the way you did the characters, people would have complained a lot more if you'd tried to do 'proper' character representations.

This was late season 2, no? A great choice for a movie. Person below me = idiot, Angel and Spike were both on it loads. Buffy season 2,3,4,7 and Angel season 1,5, not even including flashbacks.

Again with the " Person below me = idiot" because there was a loads of really well chosen sound. And I think the misspelling was purposful (accents?) but maybe you should didtch it next time.

This was JUST like an episode of Buffy, I think that was your aim and you did a great job. Make more!! (hint...post-Not Fade Away would be a great area...)

Score: 5

"its a dress-up..."

submission: Snape Dress Up

date: August 29, 2005

As far as dress-ups go, it was pretty good. Clean graphics, lots of clothing etc etc

But I don't think I'm alone in finding dress-ups verrrrry pointless. I can't see why anyone would spend more than a minute on this.

So this shows a lot of talent and I gave it 3/5, but try and make something more worthwhile next time.

Score: 7

"Great idea"

submission: Bob's Commercial Break

date: August 29, 2005

I really like the idea, these kind of games can do really well.

But as it stands, this game didn't offer much. I think you should make it into a series of mini-games, aiming fun when you go to the bathroom etc.

Also there could be puzzles, like for ordering the pizza you need to find the pizza delivery card (hidden under a rug?) and a poking stick because your fingers are too fat to dial.

Also you should be able to replay from levels when you lose. And the objectives could be at the bottom so you can see when you've completed them.

Make more please! I'll be looking forwards to it.

Score: 10

"Well made"

submission: Alien Clones

date: August 27, 2005

That was unlike any game I've played on Newgrounds, the controls felt really natural but it was hard at the same time.

I didn't get very far so I can't so much comment about variation and the like. But what I played seemed perfect all round. Well done.

Score: 8

"Still great, but not great"

submission: Blob Man 1.5

date: August 22, 2005

I've reviewed this in terms of improvement from the last one, so I had to knock off one mark.

Everything I said before still applies, it's a really nice little platformer. And it was an improvement, the background music helped, but I think an 'off' button would be good too. The boss was a good addition, but played just like the other levels in most ways.

Also, you need to customize the right click menu, I could just click 'play' and skip levels.

I think this is more of a Blob Man 1.5. So I'm still lookig forwards to a proper sequel with major improvements.