Score: 6

"Nice effect, not much of a movie though"

submission: A cry for video portal-3D

date: June 3, 2005

That was immensly impressive 3d but was over far too fast. Not much else to say...

Sorry but I disagree with the video portal idea. There's very little video added and it mught as well just be put in the flash portal. Can't see it happening any time soon.

Score: 8

"Promising"

submission: - :: Commando :: -

date: May 30, 2005

This has the workings to be a VERY good game. Just add some kind off mid battle interaction (assigning troops to different enemies etc) add more types of attackers, have multiple levels and an ultimate goal, yeh its good and I hope to see more.

Score: 6

"That wasn't Serenity"

submission: Serenity.

date: May 29, 2005

Joss Whedon's Serenity is to be the greatest movie all time, released September 30th. So imagine my excitement when I see this added to NG.

But there's no spaceships, no Mal, no River, just a bunch of sticks beating the crap out of each other. Good animation, good sound, but I'm disappointed. Don't name steal next time (not realising that the name has been taken is no excuse).

Score: 7

"Strange..."

submission: Screw B

date: May 24, 2005

...but pretty well animated, smooth with nice effects. The kilo enemies were crap, you should have used something else like other fruit or something. Fighting movies are extremely common, but this was a step above most and might survive the portal.

Score: 8

"Good submssion"

submission: Prize Fifty

date: May 23, 2005

Pretty standard movie...graphically it was good and animated well. Sound was fine all round, nice to see real speech with effort put in. The story itself was unusual...not so funny, not really sure what it was, but I enjoyed watching it. Ended a bit suddenly. Nice effort.

Score: 8

"Very nice movie"

submission: How it ended

date: May 23, 2005

Graphics- 7- Simple but did the job, maybe could have been touched up in parts

Style- 9- Thought this was really well done, the wilting rose, the pause on the grave. Very good

Sound- 9- I love Jimmy Eat World and I wanted to give this a 10 but the quality was too low, you should have compressed it a bit less, 32kbps mp3 would be about right I think

Violence- None
Interactivity- None

Humor-4- Sorry but I found the bit with the 2 girls holding hands hilarious, I'm just immature like that :)

This is really very good, hope to see more from you

Score: 9

"V.Funny"

submission: Bunbun cartoons

date: May 20, 2005

Still animations are never going to do so great on NG, but they're usually just as funny as some of the huge scoring movies, and this is no exception. Most of these strips made me laugh, I especially liked the one where he kills his girlfriend (lol) and the one where he wears the ice cream as a hat (why?!?). Not much else to say, you're a very good cartoonist and I like your work.

Score: 7

"enjoyable game"

submission: death ryder

date: May 20, 2005

I enjoyed that game, it was a good idea carried out alright. The slicing was fun but you could have had other weapons for sale, guns n stuff. The graphics were stylish at times, but often just plain crap. Times new roman for the shop signs? Cmon, you can do better than that. Google for the website cartoonsmart, I reckon you could benefit from some of the free tuts. Sound effects were pretty good, but the music sucked. Couldnt you have had slipknot or something? Generally a full song at reasonable quality is about 500kb so a 3-4 tracks wouldn't hurt the filesize too much. I reached L16, are there infinite levels? If so there shouldn't be, and each one needs to vary more (different enemies n stuff). But it was pretty good overall.

Score: 6

"Looks good...not much to do"

submission: Quin-teractive

date: May 16, 2005

Graphically this was very good- well drawn characters, nicely designed menus, smooth animation. But I though it all went to waste cause the games were pretty boring. The interactive game was just plain dull to be honest, it would be better if you could create a string of actions then play them. The range of actions was ok, but they really needed to be mixable (flying + smoking for example).

The dressup was possibly even more dull (sorry!). The only thing dressups usually have going for them is if the character can be stripped off, this was just pointless. And there weren't many clothes.

I'm trying to give a good review though cause I do really like the style. I think you should take these characters youve made and make a decent game out of them. Something fun and original. You've got talent...try and make use of it.

Score: 7

"nice try"

submission: Mini Indy

date: May 15, 2005

Not the most accomplished of games but it ran smoothly and was fun or all of 5 minutes. Graphically it was average- I though the car itself could have done with some more work. Background music could have worked. I don't think it would be too hard to have a car selection, even if it was only a choice of colours. And a track selection would be good (not sure if it would work but you could make 3 tracks then mirror them and have 6). Pretty good try